Why A.I. failed to help doctors during the worst crisis in decades
Plus: Physicists may have discovered a new force of nature.
As a co-editor on a report by the Alan Turing Institute that examines how A.I. failed to truly assist doctors during the height of the Covid-19 pandemic, data scientist Bilal Mateen saw how artificial intelligence made consistent errors. When given a mix of numerical and image datasets, A.I. couldn’t accurately predict Covid cases among the population.
“I like to think of [A.I.] as one of the many sexy technologies that exist, which is why everyone seems to want a piece of it — it’s very futuristic,” Mateen tells Sarah Wells in today’s lead story. “A.I. doesn’t have the entire context of the person in front of it.”
One of the everlasting truths of A.I. development over the last few decades is that it is very good at narrow tasks and falters when contextual thinking is required.
It’s not uncommon these days to see breathless coverage or discussions online of how such A.I. “doctors” are out-pacing humans when it comes to quick and accurate diagnoses. But while this may be true in some cases, Mateen says the A.I. has some pretty severe limitations.
I’m Nick Lucchesi, and this is Inverse Daily. Keep scrolling to read more about this story and others in this daily dispatch.
This is an adapted version of the Inverse Daily newsletter for Wednesday, September 29, 2021. Subscribe for free and earn rewards for reading every day in your inbox. ✉️
Doctors remain crucial in the era of A.I. — Sarah Wells looks into how robots and smart apps are increasingly performing medicine, but this "sexy new technology" may have just as many downsides and benefits:
The ultimate treatment patients receive from human health workers will largely determine their overall health outcomes, say A.I. researchers.
Factoring in contextual details, like a patient's medical history, their insurance, or what kind of support they receive from friends and family, are all things A.I. is not prepared to understand the way a human doctor can.
- The secret to super smart A.I. may be hidden inside an Atari cartridge
- Why A.I. knows who you find attractive better than you do
- Dead Sea Scrolls: A.I. reveals the hidden author of a crucial Bible text
Physicists may have discovered a new force of nature — Scientists found new evidence this year that muons may behave in a way that defies existing physics. Sarah Wells reports that a new, fifth force may cause their magnetism:
In the world of particle physics, you are never alone — quite literally.
Every moment there is an invisible rainstorm of subatomic particles falling on us from space. Unlike the kind of matter we’re used to — which puts up a fight if pushed up against — these tiny particles can sail right through us and straight into the Earth’s core.
As far as physicists know, these particles aren’t causing us any harm or even tickling us as they pass through unnoticed like ghosts. But the strangeness of these particles may hold a secret key to answer the universe’s most persistent questions, like the origin and essence of dark matter.
- Asteroid-chewing bacteria could help mine the Moon
- A physics experiment may have unexpectedly detected dark energy on Earth
- Olympic skateboarding doesn’t defy physics — it perfects it
Look up — Jenn Walter reports on a comet called Bernardinelli-Bernstein, for the researchers who spotted it. It’s 1,000 times larger than most comets traveling through our Solar System:
At this very moment, a massive, newly-discovered comet is hurtling toward the inner Solar System. No, it isn’t projected to hit Earth. But the reason why researchers have their eye on it is much more enjoyable. It was spotted during an analysis of images collected by the Dark Energy Survey — a collaborative project funded by global research groups. Its job is to help us better understand the properties of dark energy and universe expansion.
- Astronomers discover new dwarf planet or strange comet on eccentric orbit around the Sun
- Milky Way's comets baffle scientists with a “so unlikely” discovery
- Most pristine comet ever found may reveal the secrets of alien star systems
Sweet economics — Pokémon and Oreo teamed up for some limited-edition cookies, and fans of the series are shelling out thousands to catch 'em all. Bryan Lawver looks into what started the cookie craze:
Slap a Pikachu on pretty much anything, and it’ll sell. But even the biggest Poké-fans may be surprised at the lengths people are going to for an odd new piece of merch.
In mid-September, Oreo debuted its new collaboration with Pokémon: cookies decorated with some of the most popular ‘mons to roughly coincide with the series’ 25th anniversary. Anticipating some of the frenzy to come, Nabisco opened pre-orders for the Pokémon cookies before they showed up in stores.
- Pokémon Halloween 2021 collection is adorably spooky
- 10 exciting moments from the new 'Pokémon Legends: Arceus' trailer
- 10 best starter Pokémon of all time, ranked
- About the newsletter: Do you think it can be improved? Have a story idea? Want to share a story about the time you met an astronaut? Send those thoughts and more to firstname.lastname@example.org.
- Notable birthdays: Kevin Durant (33), Jerry Lee Lewis (86), Bryant Gumbel (73), Silvio Berlusconi (85), Halsey (27; pictured above)
- Song of the Day: “Bad Case of Loving You (Doctor, Doctor)” by Robert Palmer
- A technical note — To ensure your email open is counted toward our streak program, confirm that all the images have loaded and your ad blocker is turned off.