Scott Fawdrey

Scott Fawdrey is a freelance writer, pop culture theorist, and storyteller who focuses on the modern mythologies of Star Wars and Marvel. He is also known on Reddit as TheMediocreCritic, where he posts regularly to various Marvel and Star Wars subreddits and has almost 150,000 karma.

Scott’s biggest fears are boredom and filler episodes. He is occasionally outlandish and irrelevant but never boring.

It's a Wonderful Theory

'Ahsoka' Episode 5 Could Introduce a Shocking Alternate-Timeline Twist

It's a wonderful life in a galaxy far, far away.

Canon Fodder

Star Wars Theory Reveals a Shocking Ahsoka Twist That Redefines the Force

What exactly is the Pathway to Peridia? The answer may come from an unexpected source.

Glorious purpose

How 'Loki' Season 2 Could Bring the Fantastic Four Into the MCU

A new theory explains why Marvel’s First Family has been missing in action for so long.

Star Wars

'The Mandalorian' Season 3 Could Be Setting Up a Shocking Armorer Twist

Is this The Way?


Star Wars Theory Reveals a 'Mandalorian' Hero’s Dark Fate

What happens to Kelleran Beq? The answer may devastate you.

Star Wars

'Mandalorian' Theory Reveals a Shocking New Villain Hiding in Plain Sight

The trailers set up Bo-Katan as Din’s main antagonist, but what if that was a red herring?

Star Wars

An Epic 'Mandalorian' Season 3 Theory Reveals Din Djarin’s Ultimate Destiny

A long, long time ago...

Star Wars

'Mandalorian' Season 3’s Dumbest Side-Quest Matters More Than You Think

IG-11 and Din Djarin have a surprising amount in common.

Star Wars

'Mandalorian' Season 3 Theory Reveals a Concerning Darksaber Problem

How did Moff Gideon get the Darksaber? The answer could be more complicated than you think.

Hello There

Obi-Wan Kenobi theory reveals how Yoda can fix the show's biggest problem

An old friend could help Obi-Wan reconnect with the force and turn the tables against the inquisitors.


Obi-Wan Kenobi theory sets up a shocking Vader duel twist

Obi-Wan may face off Darth Vader more than once in the upcoming Disney+ series.

Star Wars

The Mandalorian Season 3 could steal its biggest twist from a King Arthur legend

The Star Wars series takes inspiration from two unexpected sources.