Mind and Body

Scientist debunks the most confusing myth about eating fat

How much fat you should eat depends on who you ask.

Originally Published: 
Evgeniya Porechenskaya / EyeEm/EyeEm/Getty Images

You’d be forgiven for being confused about whether or not you should eat fat. For a long time, people were told to stay well away from it entirely. But lately, fat seems to be back on the table — but only certain types of fat.

With so many conflicting messages about which types of fat to eat, it’s no wonder many people are confused about whether or not they should eat it at all. Here are just a few reasons why the advice about fat is so confusing — and how much fat you should really eat.

Some fat is essential in our diet as it gives us energy and helps us absorb certain vitamins, including vitamin A, D, and E. But there are many different types of fats and eating too much of certain types can be harmful to us.

Unsaturated fats (also called monounsaturated or polyunsaturated) are known as “good” fats and are important for helping us lower cholesterol and keep our hearts healthy. Unsaturated fats can be found in foods such as avocados, olive or peanut oils, and fish.

But saturated fats can be bad for us when eaten in excess, and can raise cholesterol and increase the risk of heart disease. Trans fats can also increase cholesterol levels. Foods that contain saturated and trans fats include butter, cheese, bacon, cookies, and fried foods.

How many calories should come from fat?

Many health authorities worldwide agree fat is an important part of a healthy diet — but that we should only get so many calories daily from fats.

The World Health Organization recommends people get no more than 30 percent of their daily calories from fat — of which only 10 percent of daily calories should be from saturated fats and less than 1 percent from trans fats.

For an average male eating 2,500 calories a day, this translates to:

  • No more than 750 calories daily from fats
  • 250 daily calories from saturated fats
  • Less than 25 calories a day from trans fats

The UK’s recommendations are much the same, limiting saturated fats to only 10 percent of our daily calorie intake — in grams, that translates to around 30 grams per day for men (around 270 calories) and 20 grams for women (around 180 calories).

But in Europe, health recommendations suggest fat should comprise between 20-35 percent of our total daily calories (500 - 875 calories). There are also no recommendations for how many calories should be from saturated or trans fats — just that these should be limited.

In the US, people are only advised to limit saturated fat intake to less than 10 percent of daily calories.

So while there seems to be agreement in how much fat people should eat, the slight variations in these recommendations — as well as variations in how much of certain types of fat we should eat — might explain the confusion over whether or not we should eat fat and how much of it we should eat.

Fact-checking fat

If all the different recommendations weren’t confusing enough, there’s also a lot of information out there that’s either too simplistic or incorrect. This makes the recommendations about eating fat all the more complicated.

For example, the Joint British Societies (which publishes recommendations to help people reduce their risk of cardiovascular disease) recommends that only around 10 percent of a person’s total fat intake should come from saturated fats.

As we typically consume 30-40 percent of our calories from fat, and international and government bodies recommend that around 30 percent of daily calories should come from fat, limiting saturated fats to 10 percent of this would mean they’d make up only 3 percent of our day’s calories. This would amount to little more than 20 grams of saturated fat — around two tablespoons of butter.

This differs from many other recommendations — such as from WHO — which states 10 percent of all the calories people eat daily should come from saturated fats.

It’s also unclear whether such a strict restriction of saturated fats would have any benefit and would be difficult for many people to achieve as a variety of healthy foods — such as olive oil — can also contain saturated fats.

Oversimplified advice on saturated fats is also confusing.

Africa Studio/ Shutterstock

There’s also a lot of advice that’s too simplistic, which can be inadvertently misleading.

For example, one tip the British Heart Foundation recommends for swapping saturated for unsaturated fats is to use spray oil or to measure oils, instead of just pouring it straight from the bottle.

But this doesn’t account for the fact that different types of oil have different saturated fat levels. Sunflower oil, for example, is already low in saturated fat, so using less would significantly reduce calories but only modestly reduce saturated fat levels.

Other advice from the British Heart Foundation includes avoiding frying foods and switching to semi-skimmed milk. But focusing on methods that have a minimal effect on saturated fat levels can make it more confusing to know which foods (and fats) to avoid.

The easiest way to avoid saturated fats is to avoid these foods:

  • Pies
  • Cakes
  • Cookies

These foods are high in saturated fats and tend to be the greatest sources of them in most peoples’ diets.

How to eat enough fat

Research suggests that we should get around a third of our energy from fat — two-thirds of which should be unsaturated fats. This translates to around 75 grams a day for women and 90 grams for men.

Of course, certain food sources will contain different types of fats and different levels of fats.

For example, avocados and pies are both high in fat. But avocados are high in healthy monounsaturated fats, which are good for heart health and can lower cholesterol. Pies, on the other hand, are high in saturated fats, which can be bad for your heart and cholesterol levels.

The easiest way to make sure you’re eating enough of the right fats is to avoid foods that contain saturated and trans fats — such as butter, hard cheeses, pies, cookies, pastries, cakes, processed meats, and chips. These foods are also high in salt, carbohydrates, and sugar, so can also have other health harms such as the increased risk of high blood pressure.

Instead, try including sources of healthy fats — such as avocados, olive oil, nuts, and fish. This will ensure that you’re not only getting enough fat in your diet but that you’re getting the right kind of fats, too.

This article was originally published on The Conversation by Duane Mellor at Aston University. Read the original article here.

This article was originally published on

Related Tags