China, Denmark, and France recommend social distancing of one meter; Australia, Germany, and Italy recommend 1.5 meters, and the US recommends six feet or 1.8 meters. The UK, meanwhile, is reconsidering its relatively large two-meter distancing rule but has attracted criticism from top scientists for doing so.
The truth is, we don’t yet know how far is far enough when it comes to coronavirus. A recent study found the virus in the air as far as four meters away from infected patients in a Covid-19 ward. But another study, touted by the WHO, concluded that the risk of transmission becomes significantly lower with a distance of one meter or more from an infected person, reducing further with increased distance.
Why such a range of “safe” distances? That’s because social distancing is a complex problem with many variable influencing factors. Here are four of the most important ones.
Respiratory droplets — When we breathe, talk, cough, and sneeze, thousands of droplets are expelled from our mouth and nose. The size of these droplets varies – some may be millimeters in size and some might be many thousands of times smaller. The larger droplets, which carry more virus particles, settle more quickly due to gravity. The smaller droplets, carrying fewer particles, can remain suspended in the air for hours.
The number and size of droplets vary depending on the activity. A cough produces more droplets overall and a greater proportion of them are larger. Breathing produces fewer droplets overall and they are generally smaller. The speed with which the droplets leave your mouth and nose also influences how far they travel – sneeze droplets will travel furthest.
Viral load — Viral load refers to the number of copies of the virus in a sample (for example, in the droplets that leave our mouth and nose). We know the number of virus copies in the respiratory samples of Covid-19 patients can vary from a few thousand to hundreds of billions per milliliter.
The viral load varies from one person to another but also depends on what stage of the illness the patient is at. We also know that people without symptoms can shed the virus.
Knowing the viral load in respiratory droplets allows us to calculate how many virus particles people may be exposed to and whether this might be enough for them to become infected.
Infectious dose — The infectious dose is the number of copies of the virus that your body needs to be exposed to in order to develop an infection. When it comes to calculating a safe distance, the closer you are to an infected person, the more likely you are to be exposed to the infectious dose by breathing in virus-laden droplets.
The infectious dose for influenza strains varies from thousands to millions of copies. We do not yet know this number for SARS-CoV-2.
In time, further research on how the virus behaves in humans and other animals, and comparisons to other viruses will help to hone this number. In any case, we can be certain that the infectious dose will vary between different people.
The environment — Whether we are indoors or outdoors, in school, at work, on public transport or in the supermarket, the flow of air, ventilation, temperature, and humidity will influence what happens to respiratory droplets.
Air currents will blow droplets around in various directions. Good ventilation will dilute the number of droplets in the air. Temperature and humidity will affect the rate at which water evaporates from droplets. All this will affect our understanding of how much distance to keep in different types of space.
Complex scenarios — With these four elements, we can begin to put together what makes a safe distance.
Let’s start with this scenario: three people are in a room that is not ventilated. One of them is infected and two are not. One of the healthy people is standing closer to the infected person – for example, 80 centimeters away – and one is further away, say two meters.
The infected person coughs, producing a cloud of droplets. The larger droplets carrying more virus particles settle more quickly due to gravity. The smaller droplets carrying less virus travel further. So the person standing closest to the infected patient is at higher risk of being exposed to infectious droplets than the one standing further away.
Of course, the above scenario is overly simple. People move around. An open window may blow air in a particular direction. The infected person may cough repeatedly during a period of time. An air conditioner might recirculate air around a room. Room temperature and humidity may result in drying leading to smaller particles carrying higher concentrations of virus. Exposure to many smaller droplets over a longer period of time may be equivalent to exposure to a few larger ones in a short period.
There is an infinite number of scenarios and having one rule that applies to them all is impossible.
This means that different countries’ rules are, ultimately, best guesses made on the basis of some of the factors described above. They cannot apply in all contexts.
It is very unlikely that you would be exposed to infectious droplets outdoors because of rapid air flow and dilution, but enclosed crowded indoor spaces are much more of a risk. We all need to do our bit to stop the spread of coronavirus, so keep your distance, preferably as far as you can.