Office buildings vacated because of Covid-19 may harbor another infection

by Anne Clayson
A view of old buildings and water towers in Midtown, Manhattan in New York City.

Global outbreaks of coronavirus have forced the closing of schools, gyms, offices, and other buildings at a scale never seen before. Now, as countries start reopening after lockdown, those previously abandoned buildings could have become a breeding ground for another infection – Legionnaires’ disease.

Legionnaires’ disease is caused by inhaling water droplets that contain the Legionella pneumophilia bacteria. It’s quite rare, but the long periods of inactivity in buildings during lockdown greatly increases the risk of outbreaks.

What is Legionnaires’ disease? — Legionnaires’ disease causes severe pneumonia. In fact, its symptoms could easily be mistaken for Covid-19. They include fever, dry cough, shortness of breath, and muscle pain. This means the potential for the increased incidence of Legionnaires’ due to missed diagnosis cannot be overstated.

Unlike Covid-19, Legionnaires’ does not spread from person to person but causes large community outbreaks through contaminated airborne water droplets from sources including showerheads, taps, cooling towers, air-conditioning systems, spa pools, hot tubs, and water fountains.

The disease can be deadly and infects multiple people at once. A recent outbreak in North Carolina saw 124 people contract the disease and four people die after walking past an infected hot tub display.

The bacteria live in warm environments, surviving in biofilm – clusters of microbial life that gather on surfaces – and feeding on pipework sludge and sediment.

Factors that lead to Legionella growth in biofilm


All water systems are at risk of this foreseeable and preventable contamination, but dormant and decommissioned buildings are especially at risk. That’s because intermittent use of buildings and equipment and the interruption of cleaning regimes increase the likelihood of water stagnation, which in turn increases the likelihood of a Legionella outbreak.

What is the risk? — The end of lockdown could not come at a worse time for potential Legionnaires’ outbreaks. The Legionella bacteria flourishes in summer months, as the optimum range for the bacteria is between 20-45°C.

Even more worryingly, countries that have had some of the most stringent lockdowns – and which as a result will have large numbers of disused buildings – are the countries where this disease is most common. France, Germany, Italy, Spain, the UK, and the Netherlands accounted for 70 percent of all cases reported in Europe in 2017. Of those, 10-15 percent of cases report a fatal outcome.

Meanwhile, the US, which has had widespread lockdowns, has experienced an 800 percent increase in reported cases over the past 20 years, probably because environmental impacts such as increased rainfall and warmer temperatures benefit the growth of Legionella.

Distribution of Legionnaires’ disease cases in the EU/EEA, 2016.

European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control

As well as the risk in public buildings, there is also the potential for increased domestic exposure as a result of the coronavirus pandemic.

Consumer buying trends report hot tub sales are surging – one online seller reported a 1600 percent increase in demand during the lockdown. As the North Carolina example shows, hot tubs can become a breeding ground for Legionnaires’ when they are not cleaned or disinfected properly.

Covid-19 vs. Legionnaires’ disease — At-risk groups for Legionnaires’ disease are largely the same as for Covid-19 – 90 percent of cases affect people over 45, and two-thirds are male. Having chronic lung disease and other illnesses such as diabetes increases your risk of severe illness from Legionnaires’ disease, just as it does for COVID-19.

But the strategy for fighting Covid-19 is not the one to adopt for Legionnaires’ disease.

People suspected of illness with Covid-19 are typically asked to self-isolate for a period of 14 days to prevent passing on the disease to others. But Legionnaires’ disease cannot be passed from person to person, and the symptoms worsen significantly over a seven-day period. As Legionnaires’ is caused by a bacteria, prompt treatment with antibiotics is vital. Delaying treatment can result in severe respiratory failure.

The additional risk of Legionnaires’ disease to recovered Covid-19 patients is currently unknown. Pre-print studies of coronavirus cases in China and Japan found that 20 percent of Covid-19 patients were also infected with Legionella bacteria. So it seems that coronavirus patients are more vulnerable to other community-acquired infections such as a Legionnaires’ and are at risk of acquiring it in hospital, as it can easily breed in medical facilities and equipment.

In the coming months, as countries re-open, negative test results for coronavirus in those presenting with influenza and severe respiratory symptoms should be immediately referred for Legionnaires’ disease testing and not simply encouraged to recuperate alone. This could have a major impact on survival and recovery rates.

How your employer should keep you safe — Legionella can rapidly become a public health problem in everyday places such as offices, schools, colleges, healthcare settings, and factories. Employers are legally required to protect worker health from Legionella infection in most jurisdictions.

As countries exit lockdown, a comprehensive assessment must be made of all water systems in premises before anyone returns to work. Effective water management programs in buildings, facilities, and plants will eliminate this public health threat.

Increasing commercial and public awareness of Legionella controls is critical in long-term disease prevention. National and local publicity on Legionnaires’ disease risks when returning to work and leisure, along with guidance on the safe re-opening of buildings should help to reduce the likelihood of disease outbreaks.

This article was originally published on The Conversation by Anne Clayson at the University of Manchester. Read the original article here.

Related Tags