Which Type of Commute Is Deadliest? A Health Expert Ranks 4 Modes of Travel

Bike, walk, drive, or train?

walking
By Hassan Vally
on
Filed Under Death, Exercise, Health & Travel

There are many ways to get around a city. You can drive a car or ride a motorcycle. In many cities, you have the option of public transport. And, of course, if you live close enough to where you are heading, you can get around in a more active way by riding a bicycle or walking.

Cycling may be dangerous in some ways, but it’s healthy, too. But do the health benefits outweigh the risks of potential death? And what about public transport or driving? What is the risk of having an accident, and are there any health benefits at all? There are a number of variables to consider, so the answers to these questions may not be as straightforward as you think.

Different Variables

In terms of safety, some things to consider include your location, distance traveled, and the time of day you’re traveling. With more people on the roads during morning and evening peak hour, this is clearly the riskiest time to travel.

Other variables, such as the quality of roads/paths, weather conditions, and your skill as a driver or rider would also come into consideration. Another variable would be your mental state as you commute. For example, are you under the influence of alcohol or are you distracted by your cellphone?

Overall though, if you live in a Western country, you are unlikely to die while traveling around the city, regardless of your mode of transport. But here are the numbers anyway.

4. Cycling

biking
Cycling is by far the healthiest way to get around the city.

Riding your bike is by far the healthiest way of getting around. Not only does it get you to your destination, it also involves moderate to high-intensity exercise.

Some might fear cycling. A recent report from the Australian Automobile Association showed 45 cyclists died on Australian roads over 12 months in 2018, compared to 25 deaths recorded over the same period in 2016-17. This is an increase of 80%. But it’s important to remember the overall population risk of having such an accident is small. If you live in a Western country, you would have to travel approximately 47km by bicycle to have a one in a million chance of dying.

And the health benefits of cycling far outweigh that risk. A 2017 study of more than 250,000 people in the UK showed cycling to work reduced your risk of death from all causes by around 40%. This study involved tracking people for around five years to look at the relationship between how they commute and a number of health outcomes.

It took into account their age, sex, socioeconomic status, ethnicity, smoking, BMI, diet, and other types of physical activity. This estimate also took into account risks cyclists often worry about, such as having an accident and exposure to pollution. So when you cycle, the health benefits that reduce your risk of dying far exceed your actual chance of dying on the road.

3. Walking

walking
The health benefits for walking aren’t the same as for cycling.

The Australian Automobile Association report showed over 12 months in 2018, 177 pedestrians were killed on the road, representing a 4.7% increase from the year before. But again, the population risk is low. If you live in a Western country, you would need to walk around 27km to have a one in a million chance of dying.

Walking is a healthy alternative for getting around, though the benefits are not as marked as with cycling, and one needs to walk a reasonable distance each week.

The same UK study as above showed walking reduced the risk of heart disease by 27%, and the risk of dying due to heart disease by around 36%. However, one appears to need to walk at least 10km each week to see this benefit.

2. Public Transport

train commute
Catching a train is actually the safest way to travel.

Public transport also appears to improve health outcomes. This may be simply due to the fact that taking public transport inevitably involves some walking. Of course, being very close to lots of people does have its downsides, such as the increased risk of exposure to contagious diseases, though the evidence on this is murky.

One study has suggested there may be a six-fold increase in your risk of getting an acute respiratory illness when taking public transport. But this study was relatively small, and the relationship between taking public transport and disease transmission was unclear. Another study actually suggested regular public transport use may build immunity, which may result in a reduction in the risk of contracting an illness.

So, there is no justification for avoiding public transport due to a fear of contracting an illness. But getting your flu shot, and even wearing a mask if you’re ok with that, can reduce any risks that may exist, especially during the cold and flu season.

And when it comes to your risk of dying from an accident, catching a train (in a Western country) is actually the safest way to travel. You would need to travel almost 10,000km to have an approximately one in a million chance of dying.

1. Car or Motorcycle

driving
Driving a car is pretty safe, when it comes to your risk of death. But there are no health benefits.

Riding a motorcycle is by far the riskiest ways to travel in terms of causing death. You are 1,000 times more likely to die from motorcycle travel than if you’re traveling by train. For around every 10km traveled on a motorcycle, you have a one in a million chance of death.

In Australia, 580 drivers (of cars) were killed in the 12 months in 2018 — up 1.8% from the previous year. But risk-wise, dying in a car accident is actually relatively unlikely, though your risk of injury is higher. You would need to travel approximately 330km to have a one in a million chance of dying. These figures indicate traveling by car is approximately seven times safer than riding a bike.

Both driving a car and riding a motorcycle have little going for them in terms of improving health. Plus, driving in peak hour traffic is pretty stressful.

So, if you want to make your daily commute a health promoting activity, cycling is the best way to go. Walking (assuming it is a reasonable distance) is pretty good, too. Taking public transport is the safest if you’re afraid of accidents, and can also be active if you walk part of the way.


This article was originally published on The Conversation by Hassan Vally. Read the original article here.