This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. Learn more

‘Fantastic Beasts 2’ Director Takes the Coward’s Way Out

The next film in the new Fantastic Beasts franchise, The Crimes of Grindelwald is pulling a magic trick of its own by making Albus Dumbledore’s sexuality disappear.

Director David Yates told Entertainment Weekly that the upcoming film will not directly show any evidence that future Hogwarts headmaster Albus Dumbledore, played here by Jude Law, is a gay man. About 10 years ago, author J.K. Rowling revealed that she’d always pictured Dumbledore as a gay man while writing the books, but there was no evidence of his sexuality in the actual Harry Potter books. Crimes of Grindlewald, which stars Law and Johnny Depp as the dark wizard Gellert Grindelwald, seemed like it might change that, as Dumbledore had fallen in love with Grindelwald.

Will we see this in the movie though?

“Not explicitly,” Yates told EW. “But, I think all the fans are aware of that. He had a very intense relationship with Grindelwald when they were young men. They fell in love with each other’s ideas, and ideology and each other.”

This is a huge cop-out. When it comes to showing diversity on the page or on the screen, extra-curricular knowledge just isn’t enough. It’s why Rowling gets criticized for retroactively making Dumbledore gay rather than showing it in any way over the course of seven books. Yates’s explanation that “the fans are aware of that” is the coward’s way out.

Article continues below

Your twice weekly guide through an endless stream of things to watch, see and play.
Sign up for our newsletter:

It’s almost worse, in a way, than last year’s trend, which saw several Hollywood make a big hullabaloo about having gay characters and reap positive news coverage, only to make the actual expression of that identity so slight as to be non-existent. Valkyrie is supposedly bisexual in Thor: Ragnarok, but would you know that if I hadn’t mentioned it just now? The Power Rangers movie proudly toted the Yellow Ranger as the first gay superhero on the big screen, but her coming out moment was a nothingburger, same as the live action Beauty and the Beast’s “exclusively gay moment.”

The Yellow Ranger in the 2017 film. 

Sure, Rowling previously hinted that we might someday see Dumbledore’s sexuality depicted in an official Harry Potter story. “As far as his sexuality is concerned … watch this space,” she said, according to EW.

But, how long do we need to watch this space for somebody to magically summon a modicum of courage? At what point will Hollywood feel comfortable showing queer identities? When can Dumbledore come out of the closet? If even having a hint of the romantic nature of his relationship with another man isn’t going to be part of the movie about that relationship, what is the point of all this?

Leaving all the hard and valuable work of showing diversity to the fans, who are “are aware of that,” is absurd. When people can see themselves in the heroes the watch on screen, that’s a good thing. Look at how Black Panther and Black Lightning are striking such a joyous chord among fans who are used to seeing white superhero after white superhero. Why not let Dumbledore do that, in some small way, for Harry Potter’s gay fans?

It’s not like anyone wants Grimes of Grindlewald to be sexy, or even a romantic drama. It’s just that it’s getting really old to hear the Harry Potter creators say that this is a part of who one of the most iconic literary characters in recent memory is, and then never, ever show it.

Dumbledore, seen here opening the doors of the closet he's trapped in, probably.

It doesn’t help that Johnny Depp, an alleged domestic abuser, is Law’s co-star in Crimes of Grindlewald, which certainly is developing a reputation for itself ahead of its November 16 release date.

Media via Saban, Warner Bros., Warner Bros

'Star Wars: Episode IX' Leak Seemingly Confirmed by Official Set Photo

The Star Wars: Episode IX title is still a mystery, but on Friday, fans got their first official look at the new movie courtesy of director J.J. Abrams. The image, which shows Rey (Daisy Ridley), Finn (John Boyega), and Poe Dameron (Oscar Isaac) in an emotional embrace is meant to mark the last day of filming for the latest Star Wars movie, but it might also confirm a pretty huge Episode 9 leak from earlier this week.

'Avengers: Endgame' Theory Says Thanos Snapped Himself in 'Infinity War'

Thanos may have snapped half of Earth’s population out of existence in Infinity War, but what if he also snapped himself? After all, the Mad Titan is transported to what looks like a different realm immediately following his snap, and brazen new theory claims he momentarily ended up in the Soul Stone universe before returning home in Avengers: Endgame.

'Game of Thrones' Season 8 Premiere Is Missing One Very Important Character

Winter has arrived in Westeros, but the Night King may be missing in action when Game of Thrones Season 8 premieres this April. A full cast list of the first episode of the show’s final season leaked this week, and while it’s full of surprising characters we didn’t expect to see again, one major absence may be even more telling.

'Fortnite' Season 8 Map Changes Coming as Earthquakes Rip Up the Island

We could be looking at a whole new map very soon.

Rumbling deep below the surface of the Fortnite: Battle Royale island is the secret that could reshape the entire map before Season 8. There’s a lot more than just the Overtime challenges to keep us busy for the rest of the month.

Players have been reporting seismic activity in the form of in-game earthquakes in Fortnite for about a week already, and things began to get more dire Thursday and Friday as huge cracks began to emerge in the ground at various locations. The first seemingly formed Thursday southwest of Tomato Temple, a second formed north of Tomato Temple, and the third emerged overnight near Lazy Links.

'Alita: Battle Angel' Ending Cameo Was "Tough Casting" That Sets Up Sequel

There is a surprise waiting at the end of Alita: Battle Angel. The new sci-fi movie from Robert Rodriguez, based on Yukito Kishiro’s manga Gunnm, has a previously unannounced celebrity and former Marvel actor playing one of the movie’s biggest roles. But who? And, most importantly, why?

In interviews with director Robert Rodriguez, he revealed that the surprise casting is meant to lock in capable actors for big roles in future Alita sequels, which was a lot tougher to pull off than it looks. (Maybe not as tough as motorball, but still.)